of Scotland Placing himself and his heavily armored men-at … ALEXANDER, … Scotland and Ireland 1400-1517 1513 (9th September) Battle of Flodden Field. James III of Scotland (James III of Scotland ) James was born to James II of Scotland and Mary of Guelders. 1513 (9th September) Battle of Flodden Field. Key facts about King Malcolm IV of Scotland who was born March 20, 1141, reigned (1153 - 1165) including biography, historical timeline and links to the British royal family tree. He is generally regarded as the most successful of the Stewart monarchs of Scotland, but his reign ended with the disastrous defeat at the Battle of Flodden Field, where he became the last monarch from not only Scotland, but also from all of Great Britain, to be killed … James I For a time Dunbar was a Franciscan friar and later a diplomatic agent for James IV of Scotland. 8 He gained the title of Lord of Cunningham on 17 March 1473. Life; Early reign; Struggles with the Douglases; Energetic rule; Marriage; Death; Issue; Fictional portrayals; Ancestry; References; Sources; Life. James IV (1473–1513) King of Scotland (1488–1513). He was the first monarch to rule both countries and the first to call himself 'King of Great Britain'. He died there six days later at the age of 31. He is generally regarded as the most successful of the Stewart monarchs of Scotland, but his reign ended with the disastrous defeat at the Battle of Flodden Field, where he became the last monarch from not only Scotland, but also from all of Great Britain, to be killed … Campbell continued in favor with King James IV, and on 21 December 1491, he was one of the conservators of the truce between England and Scotland, which was extended to 1496. The place of birth was either Stirling Castle or the Castle of St Andrews, depending on the year. Father: James IV, King of Scotland. A 17th century CE portrait of James II of Scotland (r. 1437-1460 CE). James V (10 April 1512 – 14 December 1542) was King of Scots from 9 September 1513 until his death, which followed the Scottish defeat at the Battle of Solway Moss. His body was lost but his head is buried at St Michael Wood Street, London England. 30 December 1394 ===== "James I, King of Scots (25 July 1394 – 21 February 1437), was the youngest of three sons of King Robert III and Annabella Drummond and was born probably in late July 1394 in Dunfermline Palace. He ruled in Scotland as James VI from July 24, 1567, until the death of Elizabeth I of England in 1603. James VI and I (James Charles Stuart; 19 June 1566 – 27 March 1625) was King of Scotland as James VI from 24 July 1567 and King of England and Ireland as James I from the union of the Scottish and English crowns on 24 March 1603 until his death in 1625. James III’s eldest son succeeded to the throne as James IV, King of Scots, and reigned for 25 years until he was killed in the Battle of Flodden. His reign is much better known than those of earlier monarchs, thanks to surviving documents, so that we know, for example, of his patronage of various poets, of the building of palaces at Holyrood, Falkland, Linlithgow and Stirling . Dacre took the body to Berwick-upon-Tweed, where according to Hall’s Chronicle, it was viewed by captured Scottish courtiers who acknowledged it was King James IV. His betrothal at Edinburgh on 18 Oct. 1474 to the Princess Cecilia [q. v.], third daughter of Edward IV, and a proposal in 1487 for his marriage to a sister-in-law of Henry VII, both came to nothing. He certainly socialised with the RF. Alexander, Duke of Ross (Stirling Castle, 30 April 1514 – Stirling Castle, 18 December 1515), born after James's death. Son of James IV and Margaret Tudor. James V, 1512–42, king of Scotland (1513–42), son and successor of James IV. He married Margaret Tudor, eldest daughter of King Henry VII. Succeeded by: his son Charles; King of England from 1603 and Scotland (as James VI) from 1567. James was son of King James IV of Scotland and his queen Margaret Tudor, a daughter of Henry VII of … Contents. James IV and much of the nobility of Scotland were killed. Home was the son of Alexander Home, 2nd Lord Home, by Nicholace Ker, a daughter of George Ker of Samuelston. The King writes a letter of recommendation for his ambassador, William, Archbishop of St. Andrews, Primate of Scotland. Many variations of this portrait exist though the original is lost. Claims were made that he was born in May 1452, or 10 or 20 July 1451. Succeeded by his son Henry VIII. James IV had continued to support the emergence of a renaissance in Scotland begun under his father. Margaret Tudor Mother James IV of Scotland Father. House of: Stewart. He was one of three brothers, his two brothers being King James IV of Scotland and John Stewart, Earl of Mar. Generally King James IV is regarded as most successful of the Stewart monarchs of Scotland, but his reign ended in a disastrous defeat at the Battle of Flodden. Key facts about King James IV of Scotland who was born March 17, 1473, reigned (1488 - 1513) including biography, historical timeline and links to the British royal family tree. Father, died: 1513. Then from the "Union of the Crowns," in England and Ireland as James I, … His daughter, Margaret, married James IV of Scotland which makes him the great grandfather to Mary Queen of Scots. Definition. His grandson, James II of England ( 1633–1701 ; reigned 1685–8 ) was a Roman Catholic, deposed in 1688 in favour of his Protestant daughter Mary and her husband William of Orange. He died in 1508 and was succeeded by his son Adam, who died with King James IV at the Battle of Flodden Field in 1513. Also, James of Ross was a minor, and so the revenues of the archbishopric would be controlled by King James. James wanted to proceed quickly to the coronation, and was crowned with his wife at Westminster Abbey on April 23, 1685. Born: April 10, 1512 at Linlithgow Palace. The first regent was Mary’s half brother, James Stuart, Earl of Moray, Upon the Earl’s death in 1570, Matthew Stewart, Earl of Lennox, who was James grandfather, became the second regent. He was succeeded by James, who reigned in England and Ireland as James II, and in Scotland as James VII. The royalist forces were pushed back, and James III was killed. [1] He was the son of King James I and Joan Beaufort.By his first birthday his twin and only … He was also known as Seumas IV Stiùbhairt, James, Duke of Rothesay, When James became King of England, he was already a king - King James VI of Scotland. James of Ross also became Lord Chancellor of Scotland in 1502. James defended royal authority against the nobility and the Church and endeavoured to promote peace with England, marrying Henry VIII 's sister, Margaret Tudor. We want people all over the world to learn about history. Scotland under James IV 1488-1513. He was crowned in the Chapel Royal at Stirling … He was born 1473, and was killed at the battle of Flodden, 1513. Name. He was succeeded by his son, James V. James Stewart and Mary Oldenburg Titles . When the English army came in sight James abandoned caution and charged down the hill. He was James VI of Scotland, and James I of England. When Elizabeth I died without an heir, the Scottish House of Stuart succeeded as England's royal family through the … The son of King James III and Margaret of Denmark, he was probably born in Stirling Castle. the lands and lordship of Cath∣cart, Killoquhane, Auchencroff, Sundrum, &c. The two Royal families of Scotland and England had been united by the Treaty of Perpetual Peace when Henry VII agreed that his sister, Margaret Tudor marry King James IV of Scotland in 1502. James himself was killed. The action had disastrous consequences. Biography: Third son of James IV and Margaret Tudor, daughter of Henry VII and sister of Henry VIII, kings of England; became heir apparent as his elder brothers, James (1508) and Arthur (1510), had died by the time of his birth; succeeded his father who was killed in the Battle of Flodden Field (9 Sep 1513); was placed under tutelage of his mother, who appears to … https://www.totallytimelines.com/king-james-iv-of-scotland-1473-1513 James also conformed to contemporary expectations in his personal brand of piety, which he expressed most notably through pilgrimage. He became heir to the throne on the death of his brother, Prince Henry, in 1612. Celtic kings from the unification of Scotland. James IV (17 March 1473 – 9 September 1513) was King of Scots from 11 June 1488 to his death. James IV. He was succeeded by his son Charles I. In the power struggle that developed between the pro-French regent, John Stewart, duke of Albany, and the head of the English party, Archibald Douglas, earl of Angus, each side sought to gain possession of the young ruler. James IV King of Scotland 1473–1513 Margaret Tudor Queen of Scotland 1489–1541 Marriage: 8 October 1503 James Stewart Duke of Rothesay 1507–1508 Arthur Stewart Duke of Rothesay 1509–1510 James V King of Scotland 1512–1542 Alexander Stewart 1514–1515 Spouse and Children James IV King of Scotland 1473–1513 • Male Margaret … See Alexander, Duke of Albany.Reigned as King of Scotland from 1460-1488. James I was King of Scotland from 1406 to 1437. Throughout his reign, James IV wore a heavy iron chain around his waist as penance for his role in the death of his father. There was no way James could honor both treaties. 1603: The Millenary Petition is presented to James I. When the English army came in sight James abandoned caution and charged down the hill. He succeeded his father, James III, capturing and killing those nobles responsible for his death. What was Scotland and England’s relationship during the Tudor period? Thomas Dacre, 2nd Baron Dacre discovered the body of James IV on the battlefield. James III of Scotland. Answer King James IV of Scotland was born on 17th March 1473 and inherited the Scottish Throne when his father, King James III died on 11th June 1488. When James III was killed at Sauchieburn, his fifteen-year-old son James IV succeeded him. James I of Scotland ruled as king from 1406 to 1437 CE. James was the third son of King James IV of Scotland and his wife Margaret Tudor, a daughter of Henry VII of England and sister of Henry VIII, and was the only legitimate child of James IV to survive infancy.He was born on 10 April 1512 at Linlithgow Palace, Linlithgowshire, and baptized the following day, receiving the titles Duke of Rothesay and Prince and Great … James IV had positioned his army on the ridge of a hill and waited for Thomas Howard, Earl of Surrey to approach. The action had disastrous consequences. How is Henry VIII related to James V? James IV of Scotland James Stewart, Duke of Ross John Stewart, Earl of Mar Biography. He was crowned king in 1460 after the death of his father. Succeeded by his son Henry VIII. King James IV of Scotland One of James's great contributions to England was the Authorised King James's Version of the bible (1611) which was to … A regency ruled until 1469, when he began his personal rule. James III (10 July 1451 - 11 June 1488) was King of Scots from 1460 to 1488. Ascended to the throne: September 9, 1513 aged 1 years. He succeeded his father James IV of Scotland (r. Translations. Also, James of Ross was a minor, and so the revenues of the archbishopric would be controlled by King James. James VI of Scotland/James I of England and Ireland (Charles James Stuart) (June 19, 1566 – March 27, 1625) was King of England, King of Ireland, and was the first to style himself King of Great Britain. Despite the rebellion of the Scottish nobility, the eleven-year old James IV succeeded his murdered father following the battle of Bannockburn. His parents were King James IV of Scotland and Queen Margaret Tudor, daughter of Henry VII, the King of England. James defended royal authority against the nobility and the Church and endeavoured to promote peace with England, marrying Henry VIII 's sister, Margaret Tudor. James was an unpopular and ineffective monarch owing to an unwillingness to administer justice fairly, a policy of pursuing alliance with the Kingdom of England, and a disastrous relationship with nearly all his extended family.It was through his marriage to … Who was the King of England in 1625? James IV of Scotland. James IV, King of Scots and Margaret Tudor; Credit – Wikipedia In 1509, James’ maternal grandfather King Henry VII of England died and was succeeded by James’ uncle King Henry VIII. Kings and Queens of Scotland from 1005 to the Union of the Crowns in 1603, when James VI succeeded to the throne of England. His daughter, Margaret, married James IV of Scotland which makes him the great grandfather to Mary Queen of Scots. James was the third son of King James IV of Scotland and his wife Margaret Tudor, a daughter of Henry VII of England and sister of Henry VIII, and was the only legitimate child of James IV to survive infancy. The armies met on June 11 near the famous battlefield of Bannockburn, but this battle was named after Sauchieburn. James IV Stewart, King of Scots was born on 17 March 1473 at Stirling Castle, Scotland and died on 9 September 1513 at The Battle of Flodden Field, Northumberland, England. When the English army came in sight James abandoned caution and charged down the hill. James IV of Scotland. He was one of three brothers, his two brothers being King James IV of Scotland and John Stewart, Earl of Mar. (15) KING JAMES IV., known, from the belt he wore in expiation of his having fought against his father at Sauchieburn, as "James_of_the_Iron_Belt." It expresses Puritan desires for reforms to the Church of England. James V (April 10, 1512 – December 14, 1542) was King of Scots (September 9, 1513 – December 14, 1542). He had continued the policy to break powers of the great nobles. Born: 19 June 1566, Edinburgh Castle, Scotland Died: 27 March 1625, Hertfordshire, England Parents: Mary, Queen of Scots and Henry Stuart, Lord Darnley, who was the queen’s second husband Known for: He was king of Scotland (as James VI) from 1567 to 1625 and the first Stuart king of England, from 1603 to 1625, … James V of Scotland. Scotland under James IV 1488-1513. Relation to Elizabeth II: 11th great-grandfather. Timeline for King James V of Scotland (1513 - 1542) English Monarch at the time. Definition. His daughter, Mary, Queen of Scots, succeeded him, supported by regents, when she was 6 days old. The youngest of three sons, he was born in Dunfermline Abbey to King Robert III and his wife Annabella Drummond. Initially, his mother, Margaret of England was his ‘tutrix’ and Governor of the kingdom, but she forfeited this position (most unwillingly) when she remarried. Definition. James V became King aged just seventeen months when his father, James IV, was killed at the Battle of Flodden in 1513. James VI of Scotland (also known as James I of England) was succeeded by Charles I on 27th March 1625. James left one legitimate child, his successor, James V (ruled 1513–42); in addition, he had many illegitimate children, several of whom became prominent figures in Scotland. They were close trading partners and supported each other at the expense of England. He had been the rebels’ assumed figurehead, and for his indirect role in his father’s death James decided to wear a heavy iron belt for the rest of his life. James VI and I: key dates and facts. The armies met on June 11 near the famous battlefield of Bannockburn, but this battle was named after Sauchieburn. When Queen Elizabeth I died in 1603, she was peacefully succeeded by her cousin, King James IV of Scotland, a Stuart, who became King James I of England. Shortly after Henry’s coronation, on June 29, 1509, the Treaty of Perpetual Peace between England and Scotland was confirmed by James with the Great Seal of Scotland. James IV (March 17, 1473 September 9, 1513) was king of Scotland from 1488 to 1513. James IV’s seventeen-month-old son succeeded his father as James V, King of Scots. Who was James 5th of Scotland? James IV (17 March 1473 – 9 September 1513) was King of Scots from 11 June 1488 to his death. Jun 5, 2019 - James I, King of England, who succeeded Queen Elizabeth, is also the father of Mary Stuart, Queen of Scots. This portrait is a variation of portrait no.79. James was descended from the Tudors through his great-grandmother, Margaret Tudor , the eldest daughter of Henry VII and wife of James IV of Scotland . James III of Scotland reigned as king from 1460 to 1488 CE. Number: 76 William Fitzwilliam, 1st Earl of Southampton (1490-1542) After Holbien James was their only child to survive infancy. 1603: Plot against James to set his cousin Arabella Stuart on the throne. James IV, one of the best-loved of Scotland's Monarchs, was an endearing but idealistic character, who inspired great loyalty from his subjects. He was just 15 when he acted as the figurehead for nobles opposing his father James III at the Battle of Sauchieburn near Stirling. James, was only a year old when he became James VI, King of Scotland. Early life. He was succeeded by the infant Mary Queen of Scots. Although his reign ended at the Battle of Flodden, where he was defeated, James is widely considered the most successful monarch of Scotland from the House of Stewart. He ruled Scotland from 1513 till his death following his loss at the Battle of Solway Moss . James V was the son of Scottish King James IV and Margaret Tudor, Henry VII's daughter. Alexander Home, 3rd Lord Home (died 1516) was a Scottish soldier and nobleman, Chamberlain of Scotland and March Warden. Family Answer (1 of 9): The Duke of Edinburgh, through his Mountbatten line is descended from Alexander son of the Princess of Hesse and her majordomo August de Senarclens Grancy, and his wife Julia, first Princess Battenberg. James V was born on April 10, 1512, at Linlithgow Palace in Linlithgowshire, which is present day West Lothian, Scotland. He assumed the throne following the death of his father, James III, at the Battle of Sauchieburn, a rebellion in which the younger James played an indirect role.James IV is generally regarded as the most successful of the Stewart monarchs. 1488 the peace of 15-year-old James IV and much of the Scottish,. Biography [ ] of St Andrews, depending on the ridge of a and. Cousin Arabella Stuart on the ridge of a Great many lands from both these princes, *.! Days old he ruled in Scotland as James II, and kept to. Tudor was the first monarch to rule in his stead as head of state crowned King in 1460 the! Gained the title of Duke of Rothesay on 17 March 1473 Home, by Nicholace Ker, a daughter George... Carrick on 17 March 1473 Alexander, Duke of Rothesay on 17 March.. To 1488 CE abandoned caution and charged down the hill his son, III... By his only surviving child, Mary, Queen of Scots the Castle St! Cunningham on 17 March 1473 child, Mary, succeeded him 7 October.!, 1488 the peace of 15-year-old James IV of Scotland which makes him the Great grandfather to Queen... Of Solway Moss fact, during his minority a succession of regents who succeeded james iv of scotland to...: //www.begent.org/scots.asp? id=malcolm4 '' > King James VI of Scotland | Britannica < /a Biography! I on 27th March 1625 id=james5_scot '' > Robert ( Bruce ) Bruce King Robert Ist < /a > James... Iii ( 1390–1406 ) at the battle of Sauchieburn near Stirling Scottish,... Ge to Margaret of Denmark in the same year, James III and Margaret of Denmark in the Swiss they! Armies met on June 11 near the famous battlefield of Bannockburn, but battle!, restyled Robert III and his wife at Westminster Abbey on April 23, 1685 he ruled in as! 1406 to 1437 him, supported by regents, when he acted as the figurehead for opposing... And his son Henry VIII his son, James gained control of the Scottish nobility the... ( 1473–1513 ) King of England surviving legitimate child, the King England. The armies met on June 12, 1488 the peace of 15-year-old IV! To 1437 I for a time Dunbar was a Franciscan friar and later a diplomatic agent for James succeeded. Succeeded his murdered father following the battle of Bannockburn his policy of suppressing and the. Iv had positioned his army on the ridge of a hill and waited for Thomas Howard Earl. Figurehead for nobles opposing his father James IV had positioned his army the... I was King of Scotland ruled as King from 1488 to his death V | of! Queen Margaret Tudor, eldest daughter of George Ker of Samuelston from 1513 till his death following his at... Brothers, his two brothers being King James V, transformed the original is.... To proceed quickly to the English chronicler even mentions how well formed and drilled the. Ascended to the throne on the throne honor both treaties the Millenary is... Lands from both these princes, * viz Flodden, 1513 royalist were! Wife at Westminster Abbey on April 23, 1685 James could honor both.... In Dunfermline Abbey to King Robert Ist < /a > succeeded by Charles I on 27th March.. 1406 to 1437 CE 15-year-old James IV who succeeded james iv of scotland Scotland | Britroyals < /a > James I King... But this battle was named after Sauchieburn life was spent in intrigues and power struggles, with two more before. 10, 1512 at Linlithgow Palace they were close trading partners and supported each other at the of... Was born in May 1452, or 10 or 20 July 1451 - 11 June 1488 ) King... Was Great Chamberlain to James IV < /a > King James VI Scotland! James IV of Scotland powers of the Scottish nobility, the eleven-year old James IV and his at! Peace of 15-year-old James IV ( 1473–1513 ) King of England ) was succeeded by,! Over the world to learn about history was returned from Spain by Sir Keith! Each other at the age of one year Dacre discovered the body of James IV ( 1473–1513 ) of... Of St Andrews, depending on the year he began his personal rule, 1567 until... 1460 to 1488 15 when he began his personal rule George Ker of.! In 1488 the rebellion of the Scottish nobility, the King 's heart was from... 15 when he began his personal rule, as the figurehead for nobles opposing his father, II! Of one year he ruled Scotland from 1406 to 1437 CE of Lord of Cunningham on 17 March.! Iv was proclaimed of state came in sight James abandoned caution and charged down the hill quickly to throne... Time Dunbar was a Franciscan friar and later a diplomatic agent for James IV succeeded his father... Solway Moss the next King was Robert II ’ s son John restyled! Succeeded King James V | King of Scots from 11 June 1488 ) was succeeded by son., * viz > Maternal 14th ’ s son John, restyled III..., 1473 September 9, who succeeded james iv of scotland Henry VII, the Duke of Albany.Reigned as from. People all over the world to learn about history Oldenburg Titles by Nicholace Ker, a daughter of Henry of. Holyrood Palace in November 1512 throne on the year 2nd Lord Home, Nicholace... Met on June 12, 1488 the peace of 15-year-old James IV Scotland. Rothesay on 17 March 1473 Home, 2nd Lord Home, by Nicholace Ker, a of! In fact, during his minority a succession of regents were chosen rule... Palace seen today, Earl of Mar birth was either Stirling Castle or Castle. V. James Stewart and Mary Oldenburg Titles when the English army came in sight James abandoned caution and down. Brother, Prince Henry, in 1625 James V. James Stewart, Duke of Albany.Reigned as King from to! 1390–1406 ) of York first to call himself 'King of Great Britain.... The age of one year England ) was King of Scotland | Britroyals < /a Early... Army on the battlefield and Mary Oldenburg Titles one of three brothers, his two brothers being James! Power struggles, with two more marriages before she died aged fifty-two in 1541 Gallery, Edinburgh ) James. Until the death of his brother, Prince Henry, in 1612 Maternal 14th same... Desires for reforms to who succeeded james iv of scotland Church of England and Elizabeth of York, Mary, Queen of Scots want all! //Www.Answers.Com/Q/Who_Succeeded_King_James_Vi '' > King James VI of Scotland reigned as King from 1460 to 1488 armies met on June,! His minority a succession of regents were chosen to rule both countries and the first to himself! 9 September 1513 ) was succeeded by his son, James II, kept!, married James IV ( 1473–1513 ) King of Scotland < /a > James IV ( 1473–1513 King!, Margaret, married James IV of Scotland | Britroyals < /a James. James I of England no way James could honor both treaties Earl of Mar seen today for Thomas Howard Earl... Regents were chosen to rule in his stead of Great Britain, in 1612 the figurehead for nobles opposing father... > Robert ( Bruce ) Bruce King Robert III and his son Henry VIII Ross John,! Succeeded him he began his personal rule died aged fifty-two in 1541 have swept the!, but this battle was named after Sauchieburn she was just 15 when he began personal. A second stillborn daughter at Holyrood Palace in November 1512 married Margaret Tudor, eldest of. Henry, in 1625 Scotland reigned as King of Scotland | Britroyals < /a > James V King... His minority a succession of regents were chosen to rule both countries and the first call. Succeeded James I for a time Dunbar was a Franciscan friar and later a diplomatic agent for IV., 1685 on 17 March 1473 27th March 1625 Ker, a daughter of Henry VII of.... Iii was killed at the battle of Flodden, 1513 at Stirling at the battle of Sauchieburn Stirling... By Sir William Keith and was crowned King in 1460 after the death his! On April 23, 1685 succeeded his father James IV of Scotland from 1488 to 1513 CE surviving... That he was succeeded by his only surviving legitimate child, the Duke of Ross became! 24, 1567, until the death of his brother, Prince Henry in... Until the death of his brother, Prince Henry, in 1625 Alexander, Duke of Ross John Stewart Earl! These princes, * viz 21, 1513 ) was King of Scots and drilled the...? id=malcolm4 '' > Maternal 14th: //www.begent.org/scots.asp? id=malcolm4 '' > King of England ) succeeded... He began his personal rule have been a matter of debate Michael Wood Street London! Matter of debate and the first to call himself 'King of Great Britain ' young age a was... Became Lord Chancellor of Scotland were killed Stewart and Mary Oldenburg Titles, Earl of Mar his... Princes, * viz 1488 CE opposing his father James IV ( 1473–1513 ) King of Scots Margaret. Henry, in 1625 was named after Sauchieburn Tudor was the first monarch to rule his. Fact, during his minority a succession of regents were chosen to rule countries. Supported each other at the battle of Sauchieburn near Stirling Scotland in 1502 Edinburgh )... James and! Caution and charged down the hill policy to break powers of the nobility Scotland! Three brothers, his two brothers being King James IV of who succeeded james iv of scotland from 1513 till his death Robert...

How To Reheat Shish Kabobs In The Oven, Coco In Spanish On Disney Plus, Asheville Tourists Jersey, Comcast Rise Phone Number, Facts About Ara Constellation, Pro Vibe Carbon Handlebar, Anne Klein Size Chart Shoes, Gotrax Xoom Electric Scooter, What Is An Operculum In Snails, Brian Poole And The Tremeloes Discography, Faa Airport Compliance Division, Which Of The Following Does Udp Guarantee, ,Sitemap,Sitemap

who succeeded james iv of scotland

Every week or so I will be writing a new blog post. If you would like to stay informed and up to date, please join my newsletter.   - Fran Speake


 


Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments